Hi Conall - Perhaps I didn't word what I said very well. I didn't disagree with most of what you wrote, but I do think knowing the twist in later viewings doesn't detract in the way I think you were stating (though obviously nothing can match that first viewing, in terms of surprise). I also don't think the dialogue is as bad as you claim in that opening scene, but I think our points of disagreement are perhaps more minor than I made out. I apologise.