I'm going to narrow this down a bit:

You're not a Carl. I am sure you'd go to non-multiplex cinemas if you had the opportunity/means.

You're not a Saul. If you were, you'd be spluttering snobby nonsense about The Lord of the Rings not being serious cinema in the vein of Tarkovsky, Fellini, Bergman, Godard, or Kurosawa. You're not a Susan either, trust me.

Simply liking unconventional strange films doesn't make you a Henry. You have to only like those kinds of films. Fred obviously likes every kind of film, so I'm not a Henry either.

Yes, there's some Penelope, Grace, and Fred in you (and Marlon, if you are really anti-musicals). You will, in time, evolve into a full-blown Fred, once you've finished playing fundamentalist upbringing catch-up, assuming you see the light on musicals. ;)